Berserk’s Casca Problem: Did Miura Fail His Female Lead?

Did Miura fail in writing Casca's character in Berserk

Berserk gave us one of the most iconic female characters in manga: Casca. A fierce warrior, a brilliant tactician, and the only woman in the Band of the Hawk who could go toe-to-toe with Griffith. But after the Eclipse, the story’s most traumatic event, Casca’s role shrinks to a damsel in distress, a shell of her former self. Fans have spent decades debating: Did Kentaro Miura, Berserk’s creator, fail his female lead?

This isn’t about hating Berserk, it’s a masterpiece. But Casca’s arc post-Eclipse raises tough questions. Why did Guts get to rage, grow, and seek revenge while Casca was stuck in a childlike state? Was this a thoughtful exploration of trauma, or did Miura sideline his strongest woman? Let’s break down Casca’s journey, the good and the bad.

ALSO READ: Hunter x Hunter’s Hiatus Is Genius Marketing (And We Fell For It)

Casca’s Peak: The Leader Who Outshone Griffith In Berserk

Before the Eclipse, Casca was Berserk’s secret MVP. She rose from a peasant girl to Griffith’s trusted general, leading the Band of the Hawk with strategic brilliance. She wasn’t just Guts' love interest; she saved his life multiple times and called out Griffith’s toxic ambition. Her bond with Judeau, her clashes with Guts, and her quiet loyalty made her the heart of the group.

But Casca’s strength wasn’t just physical. She represented resilience in a world that crushed women. Her traumatic backstory, being sold into sexual slavery as a child, shaped her into a fighter who trusted no one but herself. She was Berserk’s most complex character until the Eclipse ruined her.

The Eclipse: Trauma Or Plot Device?

The Eclipse is Berserk’s most infamous moment. Griffith sacrifices the Band of the Hawk to become a god, and Casca is brutally assaulted by him while Guts watches helplessly. The trauma breaks her mind, reducing her to a mute, childlike state for most of the series.

Here’s the problem: Casca’s suffering became her entire character. For over 20 volumes, she’s a passive figure, protected by Guts, carried around, and barely reacting to the world. Meanwhile, Guts processes his trauma through rage and growth. Casca’s pain is treated as a burden, not a story to explore. Even her iconic line, “Don’t touch me!” during her recovery, feels like too little, too late.

The Moonchild Arc: A Step Forward Or A Misstep?

Later in the series, Casca regains her memories and agency. The Fantasia Arc merges her consciousness with the Moonlight Boy, Griffith’s reincarnated form. While this gives her moments of clarity, it also ties her fate to Griffith again. Even healed Casca’s story revolves around men - Guts’ guilt, Griffith’s sins, and her son’s destiny.

ALSO READ: Demon Slayer’s Success Is Hurting The Anime Industry (And Here’s Why)

Worse, her recovery happens off-screen. We don’t see her reclaim her sword or confront Griffith. Compare this to Guts, who spends arcs battling his inner demons. Casca’s healing feels rushed, as if Miura didn’t know how to reintegrate her into the story.

The Double Standard: Guts Vs Casca

Guts and Casca both survive the Eclipse, but their paths diverge wildly. Guts becomes the Black Swordsman, a symbol of rage and defiance. He gets new powerful weapons, allies, and power-ups. Casca, on the other hand, becomes a symbol of victimhood. Her most heroic moment post-Eclipse? Getting kidnapped (again) in the Tower of Conviction arc.

Even female characters like Farnese and Schierke get more agency. Farnese evolves from a fanatic to a mage, while Schierke becomes Guts’ spiritual guide. Casca? She’s stuck as a plot device to motivate Guts.

Final Verdict: Miura’s Ambition Vs Execution

Did Miura fail Casca? Yes, but not entirely. Berserk is a story about cycles of trauma, and Casca’s suffering mirrors the real-world struggles of PTSD survivors. But by focusing so heavily on Guts’ journey, Miura reduced Casca to a shadow of her former self.

The later chapters hint at a better future for her. She confronts Griffith in a vision, and her bond with the Moonlight Boy suggests she’ll play a key role in the finale. But until we see Casca wield a sword again, until she fights for herself, not just her son or Guts, her arc will feel incomplete.